My 57 did not come with a 4 speed from the factory--too early of a car. The car was later fitted with a Muncie trans and a shift handle that APPEARS to be an original 57. It bolts to the Muncie shifter. Did the original 57 handles bolt to the original for 57 Borg-Warner shifter? If not, maybe the handle I have is the aftermarket one as shown in this link.
http://keenparts.com/pages/detail.ph...partnum=340002
http://keenparts.com/pages/detail.ph...partnum=340002
Comment