RIP Mr. Goodwrench - NCRS Discussion Boards

RIP Mr. Goodwrench

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Joe L.
    Beyond Control Poster
    • January 31, 1988
    • 43191

    RIP Mr. Goodwrench

    General Motors has announced that effective next February 1, the Mr. Goodwrench moniker for service and parts will be discontinued and replaced by the car line +"Certified Service (e.g. Chevrolet Certified Service, etc.).

    Sounds like "back to the future" or "deja vu all over again" to me. That's pretty much what the various GM car lines called their service and parts organizations before Mr. Goodwrench came along. According to GM Mr. Goodwrench was adopted 37 years ago, but it doesn't seem like it's been that long to me. In any event, I say "hooray". I always hated this Mr. Goodwrench thing. It sounded so trite and childish I never thought it would last a year, let alone the 37 that GM says it did-----just one of the more foolish brands that some Madison Avenue "genius" sold to GM.

    It just goes to show, though, how "cyclical" that things can be. 37 years ago service and parts branded as "Chevrolet Certified Service" or "Chevrolet Super Service" were deemed "passe". Now, they're apparently right in step with the times.

    It makes me wonder about something else, too: over the course of the last 20 years, or so, GM decided that being in the parts manufacturing business was just not the way to go. So, they spun off, sold, or outright closed virtually all of their parts manufacturing operations and turned to outside suppliers for their parts needs. In other words, they abandoned vertical integration, the pillar of their success from the beginning.

    I wonder how long it will be before someone at GM decides that what they really need to do to become a profitable and successful company again is to start a new concept called "vertical integration" and start acquiring parts manufacturing operations so that they can control costs and quality and make a profit at all levels of the manufacturing. And, if they need any help in figuring out just how to do that, they won't need to go far-----just dig out some of the books on their shelves describing how GM's original brain trust did it almost 100 years ago.

    As they say, the more things change, the more they stay the same.
    Last edited by Joe L.; November 11, 2010, 01:42 AM.
    In Appreciation of John Hinckley
  • Richard M.
    Super Moderator
    • August 31, 1988
    • 11288

    #2
    Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

    Joe......you hit the nail square on the head!!!!!!!! I agree completely.

    Comment

    • Alan S.
      Extremely Frequent Poster
      • July 31, 1989
      • 3414

      #3
      Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

      Hi Joe,
      Ironic that there was an article in the NY Times yesterday about a large redevelopment project in Traverse City Michigan. The owner credits his success in these difficult times to doing just what you describe. His company is involved in the work, and thus profits from, EVERY phase of the work to be done. Vertical Integration.
      Regards,
      Alan
      71 Coupe, 350/270, 4 speed
      Mason Dixon Chapter
      Chapter Top Flight October 2011

      Comment

      • Stuart F.
        Expired
        • August 31, 1996
        • 4676

        #4
        Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

        Just like I experienced in the GM Lcomotive Division; The new young people insist on re-inventing the wheel all over again. They won't listen to us old timers and we would continually see the same problems having to be solved all over again. I must have seemed like a genious to some of the young Engineers when I could offer them a solution right out of my desk drawer, like a Change Notice that circulated 10 or 20 years before on the same subject. They would never research the old files and records. Then too, GM loved to dump these old records as soon as possible to make more room in their antiquated buildings. I saw so much stuff end up in the trash, including original drawings, photos, artist renderings, etc.. It was a shame.

        Stu Fox

        Comment

        • Rich G.
          Extremely Frequent Poster
          • August 31, 2002
          • 1396

          #5
          Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

          Instead of changing the name, they should change the quality. I am actually afraid to take my 2007 ZO6 to a dealer for service based upon the horror stories posted on other boards. Too bad.

          Rich
          1966 L79 Convertible. Milano Maroon
          1968 L71 Coupe. Rally Red (Sold 6/21)
          1963 Corvair Monza Convertible

          Comment

          • Chuck S.
            Expired
            • March 31, 1992
            • 4668

            #6
            Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

            I was surprised to learn that Joe's interpretation of "Mr. Goodwrench" was exactly the same as mine. I also didn't think it had been 37 years when I read this news yesterday. I first remember the TV ads from the eighties(?), and that's been, uh...well...not THAT long.

            I was surprised that, like me, there were others that viewed the "Mr. Goodwrench" concept with cynicism and derision...i.e. "trite and childish". Anyone with experience trying to get their GM car repaired under warranty during those years knew the guys working on it bore absolutely no resemblance to that competent, cheerful, exceptionally helpful, not to mention, well-groomed and attractive actor portraying "Mr. Goodwrench" in the TV ads.

            You would come home after a hard day at the dealership watching every move those morons made, and those TV commercials were like a sharp stick in your eye. It was enough to incite extreme bitterness.

            This little vignette is the kernal of the truth as to why the majority of Americans buy foreign today, and it has nothing to do with lack of patriotism.

            Comment

            • Paul L.
              Expired
              • October 31, 2002
              • 1414

              #7
              Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

              I wish to make a comment on the cost and quality of parts. My daily driver is a 2007 Impala. As I live close to the necessities of life, and do not drive to work, the odometer shows only 22,000 km (13,800 miles) after less than 36 months of service.

              About six weeks ago I noticed a drone from the exhaust. That puzzled me and on examination I found severe corrosion and a hole on the TOP of the muffler at a welded seam. I dropped by to see my GM Service Advisor and he agreed that the muffler was finished and would be replaced under warranty. The part (cat-back pipe, resonator, and muffler) was ordered.

              How a part could fail so soon was beyond me. I checked the original sales brochure and it speaks of an "aluminized stainless steel" system. Why aluminize SS?? In any case the failure seemed premature and brings into question the quality of material used by the supplier.

              It took four weeks to get the parts! A comment on availability of those parts for a model that sells in the hundreds of thousands. Although a warranty job, I noted that the retail cost of the parts totalled $960.00. A wee bit dear (OK, outrageously expensive).

              So there is availability, quality, and costs lacking in a significant manner.

              I asked the Service Manager if the old system would be sent back to GM for an analysis of what went wrong in order that the manufacturing habits of the external supplier could be scrutinized. The answer was no: shipping was too expensive. I came away with the conclusion that GM simply does not care....

              One could say that my type of driving (and Canada's winters) was the cause. But I drove a 2001 Impala for six years under the same conditions with no exhaust problems at all.

              So....a poor handle by GM on external quality and costs.
              Last edited by Paul L.; November 11, 2010, 09:35 AM.

              Comment

              • Terry M.
                Beyond Control Poster
                • September 30, 1980
                • 15569

                #8
                Terry

                Comment

                • Paul L.
                  Expired
                  • October 31, 2002
                  • 1414

                  #9
                  Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

                  Terry,
                  At my 2nd-to-last oil change I asked the dealer to change the air filter element (A2962C) figuring after 2+ years it might be a good idea and for $20.00 or so it wouldn't hurt. Stupidly I did not ask the price. Some $54.04 later I was the proud owner of a genuine GM air filter. I sucked it up but that price is just ridiculous. Next time I will go to NAPA ($10.99).
                  Last edited by Paul L.; November 11, 2010, 09:50 AM.

                  Comment

                  • Paul J.
                    Expired
                    • September 9, 2008
                    • 2091

                    #10
                    Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

                    You said it, Joe. I take my machines seriously, and the moniker "Mr. Goodwrench" was just silly. It was hard enough trying to maintain some degree of brand loyalty to GM with questionable styling and declining quality, but it was even harder when thier marketing efforts were more like those for household cleaners.
                    Attached Files

                    Comment

                    • Stuart F.
                      Expired
                      • August 31, 1996
                      • 4676

                      #11
                      Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

                      The "Mr. Goodwrench" moniker conjurs up different meanings/memories for some of us. For one thing, I wasn't really much aware of it until Dale Earnheart wore it on his hood in NASCAR races. To me, he was Mr. Goodwrench.

                      Stu Fox

                      Comment

                      • Terry M.
                        Beyond Control Poster
                        • September 30, 1980
                        • 15569

                        #12
                        Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

                        Originally posted by Paul Latour (38817)
                        Terry,
                        At my 2nd-to-last oil change I asked the dealer to change the air filter element (A2962C) figuring after 2+ years it might be a good idea and for $20.00 or so it wouldn't hurt. Stupidly I did not ask the price. Some $54.04 later I was the proud owner of a genuine GM air filter. I sucked it up but that price is just ridiculous. Next time I will go to NAPA ($10.99).
                        on or off
                        Terry

                        Comment

                        • Dan D.
                          Extremely Frequent Poster
                          • November 4, 2008
                          • 1323

                          #13
                          Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

                          Three years ago I had all 4 tires stolen off my 2006 Malibu - right in my own driveway. Total cost of parts from my friendly Chevy dealer was over $2100. Insurance paid all except $125, but that is outrageous for 4 ugly steel rims, tires and plastic hubcaps. -Dan-

                          Comment

                          • Robert E.
                            Expired
                            • March 31, 2004
                            • 398

                            #14
                            Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

                            I have read in a few articles that the "Mr. Goodwrench" name will remain in Canada, lucky us.

                            4wheelsnews.com is your first and best source for all of the information you’re looking for. From general topics to more of what you would expect to find here, 4wheelsnews.com has it all. We hope you find what you are searching for!


                            Robert



                            Originally posted by Joe Lucia (12484)
                            General Motors has announced that effective next February 1, the Mr. Goodwrench moniker for service and parts will be discontinued and replaced by the car line +"Certified Service (e.g. Chevrolet Certified Service, etc.).

                            Sounds like "back to the future" or "deja vu all over again" to me. That's pretty much what the various GM car lines called their service and parts organizations before Mr. Goodwrench came along. According to GM Mr. Goodwrench was adopted 37 years ago, but it doesn't seem like it's been that long to me. In any event, I say "hooray". I always hated this Mr. Goodwrench thing. It sounded so trite and childish I never thought it would last a year, let alone the 37 that GM says it did-----just one of the more foolish brands that some Madison Avenue "genius" sold to GM.

                            It just goes to show, though, how "cyclical" that things can be. 37 years ago service and parts branded as "Chevrolet Certified Service" or "Chevrolet Super Service" were deemed "passe". Now, they're apparently right in step with the times.

                            It makes me wonder about something else, too: over the course of the last 20 years, or so, GM decided that being in the parts manufacturing business was just not the way to go. So, they spun off, sold, or outright closed virtually all of their parts manufacturing operations and turned to outside suppliers for their parts needs. In other words, they abandoned vertical integration, the pillar of their success from the beginning.

                            I wonder how long it will be before someone at GM decides that what they really need to do to become a profitable and successful company again is to start a new concept called "vertical integration" and start acquiring parts manufacturing operations so that they can control costs and quality and make a profit at all levels of the manufacturing. And, if they need any help in figuring out just how to do that, they won't need to go far-----just dig out some of the books on their shelves describing how GM's original brain trust did it almost 100 years ago.

                            As they say, the more things change, the more they stay the same.

                            Comment

                            • Robert G.
                              Expired
                              • May 31, 1990
                              • 429

                              #15
                              Re: RIP Mr. Goodwrench

                              Originally posted by Dan Dillingham (49672)
                              Three years ago I had all 4 tires stolen off my 2006 Malibu - right in my own driveway. Total cost of parts from my friendly Chevy dealer was over $2100. Insurance paid all except $125, but that is outrageous for 4 ugly steel rims, tires and plastic hubcaps. -Dan-
                              If they left the lug nuts, you're lucky. I think they're about 5 bucks each-100 dollars for all 4 wheels.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              Searching...Please wait.
                              An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because you have logged in since the previous page was loaded.

                              Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                              An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because the token has expired.

                              Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                              An internal error has occurred and the module cannot be displayed.
                              There are no results that meet this criteria.
                              Search Result for "|||"