Radiator help needed - NCRS Discussion Boards

Radiator help needed

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Michael J.
    Extremely Frequent Poster
    • January 27, 2009
    • 7118

    Radiator help needed

    I have decided to change my '67 L71's radiator out soon, after the regionals here in Oct. I would ask the experts here about 2 things. I have not done this job before, but it appears from the AIM that it is simple, just remove the fan shroud, remove the upper and lower hoses and petcock and the 2 upper radiator braces and pull it out from the 2 lower braces. Does that sound OK? Then I need a recommedation on a replacement radiator, one that will fit perfectly (?) into the old one's slots and yet be a good one for keeping this monster cool. What brands should I look for, to keep this Top Flight car that way? I have also heard Zerex is the antifreeze to use to refill. Thanks for any help here.
    Big Tanks In the High Mountains of New Mexico
  • Dick W.
    Former NCRS Director Region IV
    • June 30, 1985
    • 10483

    #2
    Re: Radiator help needed

    Buy a core from DeWitt's, or better yet, send your old radiator to them and let them recore it for you.
    Dick Whittington

    Comment

    • Michael J.
      Extremely Frequent Poster
      • January 27, 2009
      • 7118

      #3
      Re: Radiator help needed

      Originally posted by Dick Whittington (8804)
      Buy a core from DeWitt's, or better yet, send your old radiator to them and let them recore it for you.
      That's a good idea. How do they recore it? Do they put something in better at cooling than the original was?
      Big Tanks In the High Mountains of New Mexico

      Comment

      • William C.
        NCRS Past President
        • May 31, 1975
        • 6037

        #4
        Re: Radiator help needed

        It's better by virtue of being new, without whatever junk clogged yours over 45 years or so...When I had a '66 425 car once it would idle all day and never overheat. (new core)
        Bill Clupper #618

        Comment

        • Jack C.
          Extremely Frequent Poster
          • September 30, 1992
          • 1090

          #5
          Re: Radiator help needed

          IMHO, get the complete new one from Dewitt's. Save the old one. I did.
          Jack Corso
          1972 Elkhart Green LT-1 Coupe 43,200 miles
          Top Flight 1994, 2018 & 2021

          Comment

          • Dick W.
            Former NCRS Director Region IV
            • June 30, 1985
            • 10483

            #6
            Re: Radiator help needed

            Jack, my old eyes missed the complete radiatior. I am with you , buy the complete radiator. DeWitts BC67M http://bit.ly/dbscP2
            Dick Whittington

            Comment

            • Michael J.
              Extremely Frequent Poster
              • January 27, 2009
              • 7118

              #7
              Re: Radiator help needed

              Sounds like a plan, get the new one. DeWitt's also just told me they don't do recores anyway. I suspect I could get their new exact fit aluminum one (30-40% more cooling than the original) and still not lose too many points and stay Top Flight. They also have an original style with the tags and embossing, but they don't recommend it as highly as the new aluminum one. I am assuming the removal is not a huge job as I have described? No hood removal, right?
              Big Tanks In the High Mountains of New Mexico

              Comment

              • Ray G.
                Extremely Frequent Poster
                • May 31, 1986
                • 1189

                #8
                Re: Radiator help needed

                Originally posted by Michael Johnson (49879)
                Sounds like a plan, get the new one. DeWitt's also just told me they don't do recores anyway. I suspect I could get their new exact fit aluminum one (30-40% more cooling than the original) and still not lose too many points and stay Top Flight. They also have an original style with the tags and embossing, but they don't recommend it as highly as the new aluminum one. I am assuming the removal is not a huge job as I have described? No hood removal, right?
                Hello Michael;
                Search this site and google engine cooling. You'll find brass cools the best and air flow is crucial. A four core will not cool as well as a three core if the air doesn't flow through the fins.
                As far as installation. BB C2 radiator replacement is difficult. Easier with two people. We take the hood off and remove the petcock.
                Hope this info helps.
                Ray
                And when you get the choice to sit it out or dance
                I hope you dance


                Comment

                • Michael F.
                  Expired
                  • June 4, 2009
                  • 291

                  #9
                  Re: Radiator help needed

                  Originally posted by Dick Whittington (8804)
                  Buy a core from DeWitt's, or better yet, send your old radiator to them and let them recore it for you.
                  Most beautiful radiator I have ever seen. For $850+ I expected no less.

                  Comment

                  • John H.
                    Beyond Control Poster
                    • December 1, 1997
                    • 16513

                    #10
                    Re: Radiator help needed

                    Originally posted by Ray Geiger (9992)
                    You'll find brass cools the best and air flow is crucial.
                    Ray -

                    The DeWitt's exact reproduction BB copper/brass radiator (BC67M) is rated at 4242 BTU's heat rejection, and their "Direct-Fit" aluminum version of the same radiator (A66M) is rated at 5278 BTU's.

                    Comment

                    • Ray G.
                      Extremely Frequent Poster
                      • May 31, 1986
                      • 1189

                      #11
                      Re: Radiator help needed

                      Originally posted by John Hinckley (29964)
                      Ray -

                      The DeWitt's exact reproduction BB copper/brass radiator (BC67M) is rated at 4242 BTU's heat rejection, and their "Direct-Fit" aluminum version of the same radiator (A66M) is rated at 5278 BTU's.
                      Hello John;
                      A little food for thought.

                      "Radiator Repair and Replacement

                      Copyright AA1Car
                      Most radiators in late model cars are aluminum. Years ago, they were mostly copper/brass. In the 1980s, only about 24 percent of all new domestic and import vehicles were equipped with aluminum radiators. Today, that percentage is almost 100 percent.

                      Why the change to aluminum radiators? Because an aluminum radiator is much lighter than a copper/brass radiator: 5 lbs. versus 15 lbs. Empty. Aluminum radiators also contain no lead solder (which corrodes and is an environmental pollutant). The average service life of a typical aluminum radiator is actually about 10 to 12 years, which is about two to four years longer than a copper/brass radiator. Also, aluminum radiators are cheaper to manufacture.

                      Copper/brass radiators actually cool better than aluminum (almost twice as good), but the added weight and higher cost of copper makes them too expensive.

                      Radiator manufacturers have developed new, lightweight lead-free brazed copper/brass radiators that weigh less than the traditional lead-soldered radiators, but the cost is still high. These new copper/brass radiators are about 7 percent lighter and 15 percent smaller than an aluminum radiator of comparable cooling capacity. The new brazing technology for joining the tubes uses a copper/nickel/tin/phosphorus alloy which provides a stronger connection and is more environmentally friendly than lead solder. Brazing the tubes also eliminate solder bloom corrosion that can form inside older copper/brass radiators if the coolant is not changed regularly.

                      The inside and outside of the new brazed copper/brass radiators are also electroplated to improve corrosion resistance, and the radiators are also easy to repair. Furthermore, the amount of energy needed to produce one ton of copper from copper ore is only about 40 percent of that needed to produce aluminum from its ore, so the overall energy picture for copper/brass is more favorable than that of aluminum. Both metals are also highly recyclable."

                      Just some research & my 2 cents.
                      Ray
                      And when you get the choice to sit it out or dance
                      I hope you dance


                      Comment

                      • Jack C.
                        Extremely Frequent Poster
                        • September 30, 1992
                        • 1090

                        #12
                        Re: Radiator help needed

                        Installation tip: Use the cardboard box the new radiator came in and cut out two pieces to cover the fin area of the new one during installation. Once it's in, remove the cardboad and you will have a perfect, no dinged fin installation.
                        Jack Corso
                        1972 Elkhart Green LT-1 Coupe 43,200 miles
                        Top Flight 1994, 2018 & 2021

                        Comment

                        • Michael J.
                          Extremely Frequent Poster
                          • January 27, 2009
                          • 7118

                          #13
                          Re: Radiator help needed

                          Originally posted by John Hinckley (29964)
                          Ray -

                          The DeWitt's exact reproduction BB copper/brass radiator (BC67M) is rated at 4242 BTU's heat rejection, and their "Direct-Fit" aluminum version of the same radiator (A66M) is rated at 5278 BTU's.
                          This is what DeWitt's tests show, and the Direct Fit is a 2 core radiator too, vs. 4 for their exact replica. Is DeWitt's lying about the cooling tests? Ray's article seems to say so, but there must be something else going on here more than just aluminum vs. copper/brass. I asked DeWitts and they swear the Direct Fit is far superior in cooling capacity to the original style copper/brass. I would tend to believe them and have heard some other comments on the board here that would verify their new aluminum is better too. I would tend to go with the Direct Fit at this point, I am tired of replacing coolant after stop and go traffic overheating in 100 degree temps. But the old radiator has much mineral deposits on the tubes. Rodding it only helped a little, maybe that CLR solution will dissolve it all away?
                          Big Tanks In the High Mountains of New Mexico

                          Comment

                          • Jack H.
                            Extremely Frequent Poster
                            • April 1, 1990
                            • 9906

                            #14
                            Re: Radiator help needed

                            It IS more than just copper vs. aluminum! It's a matter of being apples to apples in construction/geometry which is almost NEVER the situation.

                            Copper/brass is soft and there's a limit to how much you can scale down the geometry (wall thickness and cooling fin density are two considerations). So, in addition to aluminum being lighter in weight, you can achieve different/better construction geometry and thereby surpass the cooling characteristics of a copper/brass radiator given the same external outline dimensions.

                            Bottom line, with the same external outline constraints, the internal construction geometry of an aluminum vs. copper/brass radiator are seldom the same. Hence, you wind up comparing apples to oranges...

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            Searching...Please wait.
                            An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because you have logged in since the previous page was loaded.

                            Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                            An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because the token has expired.

                            Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                            An internal error has occurred and the module cannot be displayed.
                            There are no results that meet this criteria.
                            Search Result for "|||"