Which wing nut is used on C1's - NCRS Discussion Boards

Which wing nut is used on C1's

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dino L.
    Very Frequent User
    • January 31, 1996
    • 694

    Which wing nut is used on C1's

    In this photo... are any of these wing nuts original to a 1957 Dual quad 270hp car or a 1962 340Hp car? Lets label them 1-2-3 left to right? If you have known originals on your 57 or 62 let me know....of course there is an obvious non period wing nut in the photo. Go red wings!


    1 2 3
    Attached Files
    Dino Lanno
  • Rich P.
    Expired
    • January 11, 2009
    • 1361

    #2
    Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

    1 is the style you need to show a profile picture to see if it's original.

    Comment

    • David S.
      Very Frequent User
      • November 30, 1982
      • 310

      #3
      Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

      Dino I have attached a few pictures of the wingnut from my 57 Bowtie car.
      This is the correct style.
      Dave
      Attached Files

      Comment

      • Geoff C.
        Expired
        • May 31, 1979
        • 1613

        #4
        Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

        How many different designs of air cleaner wing nuts did solid axle Corvette use? I certainly don’t know. However the chance the many were replaced over time is certain. Just like gas caps & radiator caps. So that does make true assembly difficult to discern with great certainty.

        Disregarding 6 cylinder models; do 55-62 Corvette V8 models use one design only? Or several? You can’t always go by examining part numbers, and the belief that a different design has a different pqrt number is not always fact. In addition, I know of the same part that was assigned two different part numbers.


        I wonder if other GM car line models used the same ones. Or did GM tool up to produce unique air cleaner wing nut for Corvette only?

        Hmmmmmm.

        (calendar year sales)
        Chevrolet
        Buick
        Pontiac
        Oldsmobile
        Cadillac
        53
        1,346,475
        488,755
        418,619
        334,462
        109,651
        54
        1,143,561
        444,609
        287,744
        354,001
        96,680
        55
        1,704,667
        738,814
        554,090
        583,179
        140,777
        56
        1,567,117
        572,024
        405,730
        485,458
        154,577
        57
        1,676,449
        405,086
        334,041
        384,390
        146,841
        58
        1,142,460
        241,892
        217,303
        294,374
        121,778
        59
        1,462,140
        285,089
        383,320
        382,865
        142,272
        60
        1,653,168
        253,807
        396,716
        347,142
        142,184
        61
        1,318,014
        276,754
        340,635
        317,548
        138,379
        62
        2,061,677
        521,933
        521,933
        428,853
        160,840
        Chevrolet
        Buick
        Pontiac
        Oldsmobile
        Cadillac
        15,075,728
        4,228,763
        3,860,131
        3,912,272
        1,353,979
        GM
        28,430,873
        I'll bet the club manuals have an answer - if you are chasing points.

        Comment

        • John D.
          Extremely Frequent Poster
          • November 30, 1979
          • 5507

          #5
          Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

          Love It Doc.

          Comment

          • Dino L.
            Very Frequent User
            • January 31, 1996
            • 694

            #6
            Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

            Dear David Smith, thanks so much for answering my question. The so called club manual shows your wing nut which looks identical dimensionally and tool mark wise to one of the 2 that were on my dual quad 57, as I show pictured as number 2, now my old club manual for a 62 does not picture the carbuerated wing nut but I think it is the same as my pictured number one. If someone has a photo of a wing nut on a bow tie 62 car and want to share what they think to correct would be appreciated. Just looking to learn.... not buying selling or chasing points.
            Dino Lanno

            Comment

            • David B.
              Very Frequent User
              • February 29, 1980
              • 686

              #7
              Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

              Give me a part # and your email and I should be able to forward Engineering dimensions. Wing nut is a vendor item. Can not believe what I am seeing on ebay for this item. Insanity at it's highest level!!

              Comment

              • Richard M.
                Super Moderator
                • August 31, 1988
                • 11288

                #8
                Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                Originally posted by David Bartush (3288)
                Give me a part # and your email and I should be able to forward Engineering dimensions. Wing nut is a vendor item. Can not believe what I am seeing on ebay for this item. Insanity at it's highest level!!
                Just imagine if all of us were on a Ferrari Technical Discussion Board instead of this one.

                Comment

                • Dennis C.
                  Very Frequent User
                  • June 30, 2002
                  • 883

                  #9
                  Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                  Originally posted by Dino Lanno (27248)
                  Dear David Smith, thanks so much for answering my question. The so called club manual shows your wing nut which looks identical dimensionally and tool mark wise to one of the 2 that were on my dual quad 57, as I show pictured as number 2, now my old club manual for a 62 does not picture the carbuerated wing nut but I think it is the same as my pictured number one. If someone has a photo of a wing nut on a bow tie 62 car and want to share what they think to correct would be appreciated. Just looking to learn.... not buying selling or chasing points.
                  While I can't speak about a 57 wing nut, that style would not be correct for a 62. For 62, your photo number one might be correct, but as others have said, the photo is not adequate to be sure.

                  The updated 61-62 manual has a nice photo for 62 style and, if I remember correctly, a photo of a coin test to check dimensions of wing separation.

                  Dennis

                  Comment

                  • David B.
                    Very Frequent User
                    • February 29, 1980
                    • 686

                    #10
                    Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                    Originally posted by Dino Lanno (27248)
                    In this photo... are any of these wing nuts original to a 1957 Dual quad 270hp car or a 1962 340Hp car? Lets label them 1-2-3 left to right? If you have known originals on your 57 or 62 let me know....of course there is an obvious non period wing nut in the photo. Go red wings!


                    1 2 3
                    Dino, Part # 3736162 is the correct wing nut for 57 dual quad. I do have the engineering print which shows the drawing date was 3-13-56. This was just about the time many other parts were being redesigned as a result of testing at Sebring. This would also indicate early '56 dual quad Corvettes would not use this particular item. In answer to another thread it appears that there could be 3 different wing nuts used in 56 and at least 3 different types used in 57 (1 x4 & regular FI were the same). I would guess that 3736162 was continued to be used in other years (probably thru at least 62). Since I do not have all AIM,s I can not determine what years. Have your email and will forward actual dimensions.

                    Comment

                    • Dan P.
                      Very Frequent User
                      • November 30, 1990
                      • 683

                      #11
                      Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                      David what carburation is your BowTie car. Thanks

                      Comment

                      • Bruce B.
                        Extremely Frequent Poster
                        • May 31, 1996
                        • 2930

                        #12
                        Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                        Assuming that some of the of the 28,430,873 wing nuts used by GM over the 9 year period were used on Corvettes I would say it is impossible to categorically say that "THIS" wingnut is correct for any year.
                        If these were stamped in a one cavity stamping die (tool) with a life of 200,00 pieces approximately 142 dies would have been used.
                        The wear on the die could be significant due to the thickness of the raw stock, the consistency of the materials and the configuration of the wingnut.
                        So in practice die marks, drawing defects and other surface conditions would be constantly changing on a individual die.
                        Also remember these dies were hand made by skilled Tool and Die Makers, not on CNC, EDM or other automated machines.
                        Multiply that times 142 dies and you get at least 142 different wing nuts times 200,000 without considering tooling wear.
                        You make the decision.

                        Comment

                        • David S.
                          Very Frequent User
                          • November 30, 1982
                          • 310

                          #13
                          Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                          Hi Dan,
                          My bowtie is a base engine car.
                          At are most resent National in RI in 2016 we had a very very nice bowtie candidate for judging.
                          It scored very well and it also had the same wingnut and was a 2x4 car.
                          This car will receive the bowtie its next time out at a National Convention.
                          Dave

                          Comment

                          • David B.
                            Very Frequent User
                            • February 29, 1980
                            • 686

                            #14
                            Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                            Love your math, but I think you might be a little off track on your thinking. GM Engineering Standards have dimensions and criteria for every single nut, bolt and yes, wing nut etc. used on a GM product. If wing nut 117204 is specified than that is what is ordered and used. If the part in question does not adhere to engineering standards (dimensions etc.) you will not be supplying parts in the future to GM

                            Comment

                            • Bruce B.
                              Extremely Frequent Poster
                              • May 31, 1996
                              • 2930

                              #15
                              Re: Which wing nut is used on C1's

                              David,
                              I realize that GM and every other in industry has Standards, Specifications and Drawings for all purchased and in house produced parts.
                              But on a mass produced part, to assume a stretch mark, tool mark or other characteristic is going to appear on thousands of parts produced over a multi year time period is pure speculation.
                              That is a NCRS description not a GM specification.
                              Bruce B

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              Searching...Please wait.
                              An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because you have logged in since the previous page was loaded.

                              Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                              An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because the token has expired.

                              Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                              An internal error has occurred and the module cannot be displayed.
                              There are no results that meet this criteria.
                              Search Result for "|||"